| The
rising trend in public-private-partnerships as a means of
supplying public services is benefiting a handful of companies
around the world. One British company - Serco - has become
a world leader in this market, specialising in military contracts
and, in April 2000, became part of the private consortium
that manages Britain's nuclear weapons site AWE Aldermaston.
Janet Kilburn reports
One
to watch
Janet
Kilburn
Hospitals,
schools, aviation, railways, "defence", prisons,
and nuclear weapons: in Britain there are two things these
all have in common:
1.
taxpayers money funds them (in part, if not all)
2. if they have been outsourced to private companies, there
is a strong possibility that one company will have picked
up the profit
In
1964 Serco was awarded the first private contract for managing
a British military site, the maintenance of the UK Ballistic
Missile Early Warning System at RAF Fylingdales. This was
a radical move in 1960s Britain, where nationalised industries
and state control of "vital" sectors such as defence
was the expected norm. The notion of outsourcing must have
been controversial and this "pioneering" approach
to exploiting the market in public services was well ahead
of its time.
Right
here, right now
In 2004 the company continues to profit from militarism
- though now globally rather than just in Britain - with
around 26% of its turnover relating to military contracts
worth £2.5bn (1). However, during the last 40 years
the company's horizons have broadened significantly to encompass
most public service sectors and it now offers the following
rather abstract-sounding business services (2):
1. Total Organisational Management
2. Business Process Management
3. Asset and Facilities Management
4. Consulting
5. Training
6. Specialist and Technical Services
In
recent weeks Serco has become one of the few British companies
to pick up a small but potentially lucrative reconstruction
contract in Iraq (3) (apparently they will restore air traffic
control to Baghdad and Basra - something which they failed
to do in their doomed bids for a stake in the privatised
UK project for air traffic control (4)
and that under
rather easier conditions). Apparently the firm hopes that
getting a foot in the door in Iraq will lead to greater
things. According to the UK Guardian "Confirmation
of the 18-month contract came as Serco claimed to be successfully
'exporting' private finance initiative models abroad."
Their success becomes more likely as the global nature of
public-sector funding is transformed.
Capital
and revenue
As governments worldwide feel the squeeze on public borrowing
to supply public services, companies like Serco have manoeuvred
themselves into positions that enable them to profit massively
from the resulting Public-Private-Partnership (PPP) schemes
such as Private-Finance-Initiative (PFI).
These public-private funding arrangements essentially allow
governments to hide collective debt by letting private companies
raise the finance for projects that, traditionally - in
countries like Britain ? have been entirely state-funded.
In some cases the pay-off for getting someone else to raise
the capital has been to pass over ultimate ownership of
capital assets to the contractor: "The public sector
does not own an asset (such as a hospital or school) but
pays the PFI contractor a stream of committed revenue payments
for the use of the facilities over the contract period [
]
Once the contract has expired, ownership of the asset depends
on the terms of the original contract, either remaining
with the private sector contractor, or returning to the
public sector." (5).
Profiting
from plutonium
Since 1993 British nuclear weapons production has taken
place under a GOCO system, that is, Government-Owned Contractor-Operated.
This means that while the state owns the physical sites
of production and retains a "golden share" in
AWE plc, private companies, in consortia, manage the day-to-day
functions of warhead production and maintenance. They are
also responsible for the decommissioning of old British
nuclear weapons, such as the Chevaline warheads (from Polaris
submarines) and the WE-177 free-fall bombs (now decommissioned
in entirety).
In April 2000 a new 10-year contract to manage Aldermaston,
worth an estimated £2.2bn of British taxpayers money,
was awarded to a joint venture company called AWE ML. This
comprises: the 100% British government- owned, and somewhat
beleaguered, British Nuclear Fuels Plc (BNFL); US arms giant,
Lockheed Martin; and Serco.
In January 2003, AWE ML's 10-year contract was extended
to 25 years and the value of the contract rose to £5.3bn
(6). Serco have stated that their share of the extended
contract amounts to £1bn (7).
Essentially the joint venture company AWE ML exists to try
and turn a profit out of the UK nuclear weapons programme
and associated "services". Hard to believe? Well,
its true!
Apart from the bad taste in profiteering from genocidal
weapons of mass destruction, Serco's image (and that of
their partners in crime) isn't too bad (outside of refugee,
union, antinuclear, antimilitarist, prison reform, railway,
education and health campaigner circles!), though their
Iraq contract highlights their war profiteering in a particularly
acute and modish way.
Laugh?
You could weep!
There are rumours that some customers are backing out of
prospective PFI deals with Serco, but for now the company
is laughing all the way to the bank. Their rate of growth
seems unstoppable and their global market share just keeps
expanding. In July 2003 the company reported that they were
working on 12 current PFI contracts - with an asset value
£0.7bn. They currently employ more than 35,000 staff
and have a £10.3bn forward order book.
And as Secretary to the Treasury, Paul Boateng MP, commented
in a June 2003 speech (something Serco are always keen to
remind people of):
"In the [UK] Government we see the Private Finance
Initiative as one of our most important policy successes
in our wider modernisation agenda.
The Private Finance Initiative is central to this Government's
radical agenda to deliver public services that are not just
better than they are now but truly world-class, as is right
for one of the world's largest and richest economies."
(9)
With their hope for increased "exports" of PPP
schemes worldwide, Serco look set to continue making a killing
for a long time to come.
Shareholder
action
For anti-nuclear campaigners working in opposition to British
nuclear weapons programmes, Serco's involvement in managing
the UK Atomic Weapons Establishments presented an opportunity:
here is a public company floated on the stock exchange.
For the first time it has become possible to explore a different
path of resistance to British weapons of mass destruction
- "The Way of the Shareholder".
Since 2000 women from the Aldermaston Women's Peace Camp(aign)
(AWPC) have taken on the role of "rogue" shareholders
in the company. With just one share each, a group of around
a dozen women have made it their mission to ask difficult
questions, disrupt meetings and bring "normal"
shareholder's attention to the nuclear aspect of the company's
portfolio.
With concerns at the possibility of a new generation of
nuclear weapons being developed at Aldermaston in the near
future (10), women from the camp(aign) are stepping up their
efforts to work against Serco (11).
The recent London-Aldermaston march (Easter 2004, see http://www.aldermaston2004.net)
has highlighted Britain's nuclear weapons programme in a
way not seen for several years and AWPC hope that the current
public awareness about WMDs will present greater opportunities
for women-led disarmament work.
---------------------------------------------
NOTES:
1. See http://www.serco.com/our_business/markets/defence/index.asp
for an overview of current Serco defence contracts
2. See http://www.serco.com/our_business/services/index.asp
3. See April 2004 Guardian article http://www.guardian.co.uk/Iraq/Story/0,2763,1160808,00.html
US government list of "prime contractors" in Iraq
reconstruction
http://www.export.gov/iraq/pdf/contracts03_print.pdf
4. See March 2002 Guardian article on National Air Traffic
Control Services http://www.guardian.co.uk/airlines/story/0,1371,661883,00.html
5. See http://fesportal.fes.de/pls/portal30/docs/FOLDER/BERATUNGSZENTRUM/WIPO/ppp-ukdebate.pdf
for Penny Bochum's thorough examination of UK PPPs.
Also, for a simple outline of PFI schemes (esp refinancing)
http://education.guardian.co.uk/schools/story/0,5500,519038,00.html
6. Hansard (re £5.3bn contract) http://194.128.65.4/pa/cm200203/cmhansrd/vo030122/wmstext/30122m01.htm
7. Serco 2003 highlights http://www.serco.com/media/presspacks/2004/prelims2003.asp
8. Paul Boateng speech http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/newsroom_and_speeches/speeches/chiefsecspeeches/speech_cst_100603.cfm
9. See http://www.aldermastonwpc.gn.apc.org/tng
10. This year's AGM will have taken place by the time this
pack is published. To find out how it went, see http://www.aldermastonwpc.gn.apc.org/camp_news/
Further
reading:
Previous JK art http://www.peacenews.info/issues/2442/244222.html
2000 Ethical Consumer article http://www.ethicalconsumer.org/magazine/corpwatch/serco.htm
|